I Just Work Here: A sincere message for the jobless among us as benefits run out


Published Dec 23, 2013 at 3:00 am (Updated Dec 22, 2013)

IT APPEARS that on Dec. 28, barring unexpected political action that would amount to a true Christmas miracle, 1.3 million jobless Americans will stop receiving unemployment benefits.

This is to those people:

I’m sorry this is happening.

I’m sorry our political leaders lack the foresight or compassion to honestly address this issue, and to understand the economic realities unemployed people in this country face.

I’m sorry that people like Sen. Rand Paul of Kentucky believe that extending unemployment benefits beyond 26 weeks is a “disservice” to all of you. I’m sorry that he recently said: “When you allow people to be on unemployment insurance for 99 weeks, you’re causing them to become part of this perpetual unemployed group in our economy.”

First off, there’s no state in the country where a person can be on unemployment for 99 weeks. That’s factually incorrect.

The longest period of time a person can get state and federal unemployment benefits is 73 weeks, and that, according to data from the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, is only in Illinois, Rhode Island and Nevada, states that have unemployment rates in the neighborhood of 9 percent.

The length of unemployment benefit eligibility in other states ranges from 19 to 63 weeks, depending on each state’s unemployment rate.

More importantly, the implication that receiving unemployment checks causes people to stay unemployed is off base.

The belief, I guess, is that 1.3 million unemployed Americans grow so addicted to receiving, on average, about $300 a week that you lose all interest in working for a living. Because who wouldn’t be perfectly comfortable keeping a family afloat while pulling in around $15,000 a year?

But to get your benefits, you have to be actively seeking a job and providing proof of your efforts. And most Americans are honest and hardworking people who don’t like being on unemployment and will fight and scratch and claw like mad to find jobs.

And that, my friends, is the problem. Paul and others seem to think that as soon as you know there will be no more unemployment checks coming, then and only then will you get serious about finding work.

That’s nonsense.

According to the Department of Labor’s Bureau of Labor Statistics, there were 10.9 million unemployed people in this country as of Dec. 6. At the end of October — which is the most recent data available — there were 3.9 million job openings.

How do you make that work? How do you say that people who have been unemployed for more than 26 weeks are going to hop to it and find work when there’s about one job opening for every three unemployed people?

Furthermore, research does not support the claim that extending unemployment benefits keeps people unemployed.

A paper published in April by Henry Farber of Princeton University and Robert Valletta of the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco found that “extended benefits do not delay the time to re-employment substantially.”

This was an important study because it examined the dynamics of the current recession. Many economists have said that some studies claiming extended unemployment benefits have a disincentive effect are based on data from the 1970s and 1980s that are no longer applicable.

In testimony before Congress in 2010, economist Lawrence Katz of Harvard University said that “the most compelling research suggests only modest impacts of UI (unemployment insurance) extensions on the search effort and duration of unemployment of unemployment insurance recipients.”

People on both sides of this issue can toss studies around, but let’s look at this as decent human beings. Are there people receiving unemployment benefits who take advantage of the system? Of course there are. Take any system and there will be people manipulating it to their own ends.

But where do people get off assuming a majority of unemployed people are nursing the system? Who looks at their friends and relatives and neighbors — and who among us doesn’t know someone who has lost a job? — and assumes they’re just fine coasting on government assistance?

That’s cynical.

The unemployment rate is trending down, and there are signs of economic improvement. But it’s not there yet, and cutting off what for many jobless people is a lifeline will only make things worse.

I recognize the need for fiscal restraint. But the $25 billion needed to extended unemployment insurance over the next two years is a fraction of our overall budget, and it’s money that circulates swiftly back into the economy.

We are a nation of good-hearted and hardworking people. That shouldn’t get lost in a turbulent sea of conflicting ideologies.

I am sorry to each and every one of you — all 1.3 million — who will lose your unemployment benefits.

You deserve help, not a political brushoff.

And you deserve leaders who deal in facts rather than fiction, and who believe that we are at our best when we see the good in everyone.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized, Unemployment and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to I Just Work Here: A sincere message for the jobless among us as benefits run out

  1. weggieboy says:

    Well said, and, as anyone who’s followed this blog for any length of time knows, you speak from direct experience. I’m reblogging this on my blog because it says so powerfully, so much better what I feel about the insane politics of Washington these days. Only it took you to say it.

  2. weggieboy says:

    Reblogged this on weggieboy's blog and commented:
    Aside from being one of the better blogs I follow, the person who writes it is a thoughtful, articulate woman whose ability to pinpoint the heart of a situation is admirable.

  3. weggieboy says:

    (I just noticed you didn’t write it, but my comments about your insight into this issue still stand. You selected a perfect article to express what needs to be said about extending unemployment benefits.)

  4. And yet . . . even in the UK the concept of the unemployed “on the dole” and actively NOT seeking work is so universally accepted that the Andy Capp comic has used it as the basis for jokes for DECADES. Most recent example: http://www.gocomics.com/andycapp/2013/12/20#.Urma87Twgjo
    I personally know a man who stated frankly to all his friends that unemployment benefits were a “vacation” to him and that he’d start looking for a new job only as his benefit period drew to a close. That’s only one man, but . . . you can’t pretend this doesn’t exist. Is it awful to be unemployed? Yes, for most of us. Are there many who are using their benefits sensibly while honestly seeking work? Yes. Is more than a year enough time to find a new job? Not always. But where do you draw the line when you’ve removed the person-to-person connection for the aid and replaced it with government bureaucracy?

    • Natasha says:

      Some people treat unemployment as a vacation. Many of us though became disheartened as we applied for and were rejected for hundreds of jobs as we faced the end of unemployment benefits.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s